Dodgers Wild Card Roster: Three Catchers and Conforto’s Absence – What it Means for October Baseball

The Los Angeles Dodgers have announced a surprising roster decision for their Wild Card series against the Cincinnati Reds, opting to carry three catchers. This move, coupled with the absence of outfielder Michael Conforto, signals a strategic gamble as they enter the postseason.

The inclusion of three catchers – Will Smith, Austin Barnes, and a third, yet-to-be-named player (likely Diego Cartaya or another young prospect) – highlights the Dodgers’ concerns about Will Smith’s health. Smith, the team’s starting catcher, has been battling a hairline fracture in his right hand. While he’s expected to play, carrying two additional catchers provides crucial insurance should the injury flare up or require him to be removed from a game. It also allows for greater flexibility in pinch-hitting situations, particularly in late innings. The third catcher could also serve as a designated runner in high leverage spots. While Barnes’ offensive capabilities are limited, his experience and defensive prowess are invaluable, especially in managing the pitching staff and handling high-pressure situations.

However, the decision to carry three catchers comes at a cost. It means sacrificing a roster spot that could have been used for another position player or an additional reliever. This is particularly notable considering Michael Conforto’s absence from the roster. Conforto, signed in the offseason to provide offensive firepower, has struggled with consistency and injuries throughout the season. His exclusion suggests the Dodgers believe other players offer a better chance of contributing to the team’s success in the Wild Card series. That player could be Manuel Margot, with his speed on the base paths and his ability to play excellent defense in all three outfield positions.

The Dodgers’ strategy indicates a focus on defense, pitching management, and maximizing every at-bat. Manager Dave Roberts is clearly prioritizing contingency planning and strategic matchups over pure offensive firepower. This approach could be effective in a short series, where small advantages can make all the difference. However, it also carries risk. If the Dodgers struggle to score runs, the absence of Conforto’s potential power could be felt. Ultimately, the success of this unconventional roster construction will depend on the health of Will Smith, the effectiveness of the pitching staff, and the ability of the remaining hitters to capitalize on scoring opportunities. The Reds, with their own potent offense and aggressive baserunning, will undoubtedly test the Dodgers’ strategy. Get ready for some tense and exciting baseball!